The world is still askew

Coblence, allied soldier
Coblence, allied soldier

A shaky German republic, disagreements among the Allies.

[Rhineland, 1920] Thank God, the putsch in Berlin and the following Ruhr crisis were over. In Coblenz too it had been days full of tension for the American forces when Reichswehr troops advance more into the Ruhr area, which contravened the Treaty of Versailles. French troops had occupied Frankfurt, Hanau and Darmstadt.

Seen from the American side

When news spread about the putsch in Berlin, General Allen had been asked to send trains, to get Americans desiring to leave out of Berlin and Leipzig. It had to happen fast as the German Government would not guarantee their safety.

Chiara had been enraged when the Kapp government had annulled the minutes and the Constitution of the Weimar Assembly. Not for a moment had she believed their declaration for a republic and for the execution of the Versailly Peace Treaty. In her heart, she was by Kathi’s and Max’ side, demonstrating against the putsch. Then there was the uprising in the Ruhr area, bloodily suppressed by Reichswehr and Free Corps troops. She had feared with Kathi for Max.

Germany was far from being a stable democracy in peace. Extremists from the Left and the Right struggled to overthrow the government, which in turn had lost credibility among its own people by giving right wing troops a free hand.


Chiara did not believe in many officers’ openness for peace, she thought they were just waiting for their time to come. And they did not see that things could be a lot worse for Germany. There could no longer be any doubt that Germany is doing her utmost to maintain a force vastly superior to that laid down in the treaty, it is a question whether the militarists are not out of hand and stronger than the government.

Disagreements among the Allies

On May 19, 1920 Major General Allen was appointed as the American observer on the Rhineland High Commission. His mission to the Rhineland had become not only a military, but also a political one. For all his sympathy and compassion for France, Allen thought that French General Foch “might have lost sight of the general welfare for the coming years”, and that his “military attitude” to hold Germany down for years was wrong. For Allen, “team-work between the Allies was crucial, a great value to the world and to France in particular, that neither English nor American troops leave the Rhine now.”*

Suspicion and disagreements among the Allies grew. On the Rhineland Commission, its French President Tirard often talked as if England and the USA were not giving his country the support it needed and deserved, as if they did not see how much France had suffered.

Chiara thought of all the American Forces in Germany were contributing to rebuilt Europe whereas some of their Allies seemed at a war after the war. “The Allies were demanding 810,000 milk cows from Germany, while the United States were spending large sums of money toward feeding the undernourished children in Germany. “General Allen is right,” she thought, “the world is still askew and its various states are working at cross-purposes.”*

Winter 1920

At Christmas, Chiara and John met again with their German family. Chiara loved the coats Helene had made from uniform cloth. A ray of sunshine after a year of violence, putsches and attempted murders. Who knew what the next year would bring? Besides, the Allies were still negotiating the amount of reparations imposed on Germany.

“You know about the devastations in France, don’t you?” Chiara asked, “entire regions have been blasted into oblivion.” “Yes”, Kathi answered very sadly, “Papa told us about France, and Uncle Joscha about Belgium. We pray that one day we will reconcile with France and Belgium.” “I’m afraid the right-wing hardliners bear mortal hatred against democratic politicians who think so, who seek understanding”, her husband Max added, “there have been two attempts to murder Erzberger, thank God they failed. You know what Hindenburg and Ludendorff say, that the German army was defeated by a ‘stab in the back’. Now the republicans have to pay for defeat, occupation and reparations. If we do manage soon to get our country back on its feet, the evil seed will sprout.” Kathi nodded. “It may sound weird to put one’s hopes on foreign troops in one’s country, yet I do hope that the American Forces will remain in Germany until the worst is behind us. You can mediate between hard stances and find a pragmatic solution.”

John nodded. “I think Major General Allen would quite agree. He has deepest sympathies for France and understands its fears. Germany is an overwhelming neighbor, its population is a lot bigger than France’s, and now that entire regions are devastated, France is thrown back economically for years. Therefore, France wants to hold Germany down for years to come. But that will only sow new hatred. Europe can only get back on its feet and thrive again, if we have peace at the Rhine.”

* Quoted from Henry T. Allen, My Rhineland Journal.

The photo is from the German Wikipedia, public domain section.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.